Also painted my toenails with the ELF polish I just got. I have to say I'm very satisfied with their nail polish! This color is "Blush," a soft, metallic, coppery rose color (nail art stickers courtesy Dana!) The ELF polish dries pretty quickly and doesn't chip right away like a lot of people said (for me at least). Their swatches aren't the most accurate, but the colors I got are still pretty nonetheless. I would definitely pay $1 for this nail polish.
Also, here's some swatches of the polishes from Dana and my ELF haul. Click to biggify.